I recently received a copy of a letter to First Lady Michelle Obama from a formerly dual U.S. and Canadian citizen, who chose to give up his U.S. citizenship. It speaks to some of the reasons that record numbers are renouncing their U.S. citizenship. The letter is reminiscent of Dear Mr. President, Why I’m Leaving America. The author noted that the letter to Mrs. Obama was a response to a political missive in which Mrs. Obama sought support for the Democratic Party in the upcoming Presidential election.
But the issue is far deeper. The broader context is America’s global tax system, worldwide reporting, FATCA, FBARs, and all of the ways in which the United States has made life difficult for U.S. persons abroad. That includes those who are just over our northern border into Canada. Canadians may be famously civil and reasonable, but a few are now saying I Am Canada, Hear Me Roar.
"Dear Mrs. Obama:
I gave up my U.S. citizenship this year, so I cannot vote. And if I could, I wouldn’t vote Democrat. It’s not that I hate liberals. I am one. And the Republicans honestly make me sick. The bottom line is America has lost its way in this world, and neither party, in my humble opinion, is going to make any headway in making it better.
I have lived abroad most of my life. This is my 46th year in Canada. I married Canadian, my kids are Canadian, not American, I have worked my entire life in Canada. I invest here, and will retire here. I am Canadian, but as you are likely aware, giving up that USA brand is not easy. I have many relatives living in the 50. I used to love to visit them. At the moment, I couldn’t care less if I ever cross that border again.